Sheetz Chicken Sandwich
A full chicken fillet sandwich you can order crispy or grilled, stacked on a bun with your choice of sauce and toppings — built fresh through the same Made-To-Order kitchen as the rest of the menu.
On this page
What Is the Sheetz Chicken Sandwich?
The chicken sandwich is the full-meal answer on the Sheetz chicken lineup, sitting opposite the finger-food-style tenders. Where tenders are meant for quick eating or sharing, the sandwich is built like a proper sandwich order — a chicken fillet on a bun, dressed with sauce and toppings, meant to be eaten as a single satisfying meal rather than split up.
The headline choice when ordering is crispy versus grilled. The crispy version gets a breaded coating that crisps up on the line, giving you the same kind of texture you'd expect from a fried chicken sandwich elsewhere, while the grilled version skips the breading in favor of a leaner, char-marked fillet. Neither option is positioned as the "default" — you're prompted to choose at the kiosk or in the app, so it's worth deciding ahead of time whether you're in the mood for something crunchier or something a bit lighter.
From there, the sandwich opens up the same way any other MTO order does. Bun choice, sauce selection and topping additions are all handled on the same ordering screen, so a "chicken sandwich" at Sheetz isn't really one fixed item — it's more of a starting template that two different customers can walk away with in very different forms. Some people keep it simple with just a bit of mayo and lettuce, while others load it up with extra cheese, pickles, or a spicier sauce swapped in for something milder.
Compared to the fish sandwich on the menu, the chicken sandwich tends to be the heartier, more filling pick, while fish leans a little lighter depending on how it's built. If you're deciding between the two, it often comes down to whether you're in more of a chicken mood or want to switch things up — both run through the same customization system, so neither one requires extra effort to make your own.
Price & Why It Can Vary
The Chicken Sandwich starts at roughly $6.99, which covers the base build before any extras. As with most items on the menu, that number moves depending on a few factors.
Location is a big one — stores in areas with a higher cost of living generally price sandwiches a bit higher than stores in smaller towns, even though the base sandwich is technically identical. Choosing the crispy or grilled fillet doesn't usually change the price on its own, but adding extra cheese, bacon, or premium sauces typically does. Ordering the sandwich as part of a combo with a side and drink will also change your total compared to ordering it by itself. For the exact price at your store, the Sheetz app shows current, location-specific pricing before you finalize your order, which is the most reliable way to avoid surprises at checkout.
Nutrition Snapshot
| Metric | Approximate Value |
|---|---|
| Calories | ~520 cal (approximate estimate for a standard crispy build) |
| Serving | 1 sandwich |
| Customization | Crispy vs. grilled, bun, sauce and toppings all change the calorie count |
These figures are an approximate estimate, not a verified precise value, and a grilled build will typically run lower in calories than a crispy one. Check the Sheetz app or in-store nutrition panel for a build-specific number. See our full Nutrition & Calories guide for more items.
Why the Chicken Sandwich Stands Out
- A real crispy-or-grilled choice. Most convenience-store chicken sandwiches only come one way. Here you're actually asked, every time, which fillet style you want.
- Built to be a full meal. At roughly 520 calories, it's sized to stand on its own rather than needing a side to feel like real food.
- Deep customization. Bun, sauce and toppings are all adjustable on the same build screen, so the same base sandwich can go from simple to fully loaded.
- Consistent no matter the build. Whether you order it plain or piled with extras, it still comes off the same MTO line as everything else, so wait times don't jump much for a more complex order.
How to Order This Item
In-Store Kiosk: Search "Chicken Sandwich" under the Chicken tab, pick crispy or grilled first, then work through bun, sauce and topping choices on the build screen.
Mobile App: Order ahead through the Sheetz app and save your go-to build — crispy with a specific sauce combo, for example — so you're not re-selecting every topping each time.
Delivery: Available through partner delivery apps at many locations. It travels reasonably well since it's a sturdier sandwich, though asking for sauce on the side helps keep the bun from getting soggy on a longer ride.
I used to default to the crispy fillet every time, mostly out of habit, until a coworker talked me into trying the grilled version on a whim. It genuinely surprised me — it's not the dry, flavorless "diet" option grilled chicken sandwiches sometimes turn into elsewhere. Now I actually alternate depending on what else I'm eating that day. If you're ordering for the first time, my advice is to not overthink the sauce choice; a simple mayo-and-pickle combo lets the fillet itself do the talking.
Quick Questions
Can I get the Sheetz chicken sandwich grilled instead of crispy?
Yes. The chicken sandwich is built through the Made-To-Order system, so you can choose between a crispy breaded fillet or a grilled fillet when you place your order.
What toppings and sauces can I add to the chicken sandwich?
You can customize the bun, sauce and toppings at the kiosk or in the app, similar to building a burger or sub. Options vary by store, so check your location's ordering screen for the full list.
Is the chicken sandwich a full meal on its own?
For most people, yes. At roughly 520 calories for a standard crispy build, it's substantial enough to work as a standalone meal. If you want more food, pairing it with a side and a drink from a combo turns it into a heartier sit-down meal.
How does the chicken sandwich compare to the fish sandwich?
They share the same bun-and-topping format and a similar starting price, but the chicken sandwich offers a grilled option alongside crispy, while the fish sandwich is breaded and fried only. Chicken also tends to run a bit heartier, while fish is the pick if you want a change of pace from poultry and beef.
Can I order the chicken sandwich through the Sheetz app or with delivery?
Yes. It's fully customizable through the Sheetz mobile app and in-store kiosk, and it's also available through partner delivery apps at many locations.
Related Items
Chicken Tenders
Fish Sandwich
